Tuesday, October 30, 2012

Capital Punishment Should Be Abolished



On February 17, 2004, Cameron Willingham was executed for allegedly killing his three daughters by setting fire to the family home.  Eight years after his execution, he might be pardoned.

Texas’s state fire marshal gave the primary testimony against Willingham, saying that burn patterns on the floor and cracks in the window are indicative of accelerants.  The Texas Forensic Science Commission, founded seven years ago to combat wrongful convictions, recently investigated the case and declared the fire marshal’s claims insupportable, according to Ethan Bronner of The New York Times.
Willingham’s case isn’t the first wrongful conviction to have surfaced.  A national total of 300 people have been exonerated after being convicted, and 141 of the convicted were on death row. Because most death row facilities have uniform conditions, that means one hundred forty-one innocent men and women lived in approximately 60-square-foot cells, exercised alone in cages, and ate every meal alone for an average of ten years.
The solution for this problem is clear: abolish capital punishment.  Prison is not only better for the convicted but also for the United States as a whole.  For the past several years our country has been on an economic decline, and death row is contributing to that.  On average, it costs $2 million to put a person on death row, whereas it costs $500,000 to put a person in prison for life.  Taxpayers are paying four times more to take “an eye for an eye.”
Economic reasoning aside, life without parole is generally more humane than capital punishment. Through capital punishment, the mentally ill have been executed, the innocent have been executed, and more people than necessary have suffered.  Supporters of capital punishment say these repercussions are the price that must be paid to get murderers off the streets.  But we must ask ourselves—is this the best, most efficient way to do so? Death row is, overall, a method of revenge that has helped warp the values of our society.
Cameron Willingham’s last words were “Please clear my name.  I did not kill my children.”  An innocent father may have been executed.

No comments:

Post a Comment